*Last Updated: July 2024

The 5 Best Broiler Pans | Buying Guide

In this post, we ranked the best-selling broiler pans on the market.

In today’s health-conscious age, broiling should be an increasingly popular cooking method.

For many, however, implementing a healthier cooking alternative to frying, is a tough task.

Health Benefits?

If you’re looking for a healthier cooking method, consider forgoing frying. Frying adds calories and fat to your food, increases your risk of coronary artery disease and weight gain, and instead opt for broiling instead.

Apart from being heart-healthy and diet-friendly, broiling is cheap and fast too, which perhaps explains its growing popularity. And once you have decided to broil your food, a broiler pan is what you would need (Source).


Comparing The Options

SaleBestseller No. 1
Whirlpool 4396923 Genuine OEM Premium Broiler Pan
  • WHIRLPOOL GENUINE OEM Parts & Accessories are designed specifically for your appliance, meet tested engineering standards, and are crafted to ensure the quality of your appliance.
Bestseller No. 2
GE Appliances Broiler Pan with Rack for Oven, Non-Stick Pan, 2 Piece Black Porcelain Coated Carbon Steel Roasting Pan, Durable and Dishwasher Safe, WB48X10056, Genuine GE OEM Part
  • DESIGNED FOR OPTIMAL ROASTING: roasting rack set holds food above the grid to allow air to circulate completely around all surfaces during the cooking cycle.
SaleBestseller No. 4
Range Kleen BP100 Porcelain Broiler Pan with Chrome Grill, 2-piece , 16.5 inches
441 Reviews
Range Kleen BP100 Porcelain Broiler Pan with Chrome Grill, 2-piece , 16.5 inches
  • FAT-FREE COOKING: Grate on grill allows drippings to drain fat away from meats. A healthier meal with an added crispness that your family will love!

Buying Guide

Before buying a broiler pan, you should have a clear idea about why you want to possess one. Just because everyone else is buying shouldn’t mean you too should go ahead, get one and then forget all about it.

So, first things first: why you need a broiler pan? To answer, it would speed up your cooking process, need less oil, and let you reduce the natural fat present in your meat or fish, which would melt during broiling and drip into the broiler pan. Once you have finished cooking, you can discard these fat drippings.

Once you know the benefits of a broiler pan and are ready to use one, you should consider four key factors before you buy one:

  • The material it’s made up of
  • Maintenance
  • The type of food you plan to cook
  • The pan’s size

Though different materials could be used to build your broiler pan, the typical ones are carbon steel, ceramic, cast iron, and stainless steel.

Though all these materials can handle the task of broiling well, they have some specific properties that suit particular recipes or foods the best. For instance, stainless steel can help you make great roasts, while a recipe requiring heat to be distributed evenly across its surface would be best done in a cast iron broiler pan.

If you don’t want to spend your precious time scrubbing your broiler pan away at the sink, investing in one that’s dishwasher safe would be a good bet. Even when you can do without a dishwasher-safe cookware, it’s prudent to read some user reviews before buying your piece to ensure you get one that’s easy to clean and maintain.

The type of food you plan to cook is another important factor to consider. If you want to cook meat most of the time, buying a broiler pan that comes with a grill-style rack or has a grate with wide open slits to make the drippings pass through them easily would be a prudent choice. In case broiling vegetables is your priority, opting for a pan having more surface area on its top rack would be a good idea.

Before you buy a pan, you should make sure of the dimensions that would fit into your oven. It would be ideal to measure your oven’s dimensions first, and then buy a pan whose size would comfortably fit into it.

Popular Broiler Recipes

Recipe NameLink (From Food Network)RatingRecipe Time
Sheet Pan Chicken Fajitashttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/sheet-pan-chicken-fajitas-368027234 Reviews30 minutes
Garlic Breadhttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/rachael-ray/garlic-bread-recipe-195170692 Reviews8 minutes
Crispy Skin Salmonhttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/claire-robinson/crispy-skin-salmon-recipe-192397238 Reviews37 minutes
Bacon-Wrapped Shrimphttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/bacon-wrapped-shrimp-33636287 Reviews40 minutes
Pork Chops and Ricehttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/trisha-yearwood/pork-chops-and-rice-recipe-2124315104 Reviews1 hour
Whole30 Coconut-Crusted Shrimp with Pineapple-Chili Saucehttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/whole30-coconut-crusted-shrimp-with-pineapple-chili-sauce-38818128 Reviews25 minutes
Sheet Pan Party Fajitashttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/sheet-pan-party-fajitas-37500553 Reviews35 minutes
Marinated Lamb Chopshttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/ellie-krieger/marinated-lamb-chops-recipe-194616243 Reviews1 hour 23 minutes
Broiled Halibut with Bechamel Saucehttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/giada-de-laurentiis/broiled-halibut-with-bechamel-sauce-recipe-192467341 Reviews34 minutes
Simple Broiled Flank Steak with Herb Oilhttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/simple-broiled-flank-steak-with-herb-oil-33628784 Reviews30 minutes
Tuna Melthttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/tuna-melt-recipe-212545218 ReviewsN/A
French Onion Souphttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/tyler-florence/french-onion-soup-recipe2-1947434723 Reviews1 hour 10 minutes
Chicken Meatballshttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/melissa-darabian/chicken-meatballs-recipe-20432847 Reviews1 hour 30 minutes
Grilled Hassleback Sweet Potatoes with Molasses-Nutmeg Butterhttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/bobby-flay/grilled-hassleback-sweet-potatoes-with-molasses-nutmeg-butter-21815474 Reviews1 hour
Real Hamburgershttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/ina-garten/real-hamburgers-recipe-1941208109 Reviews30 minutes
Rao's Famous Lemon Chicken (Pollo al Limone)https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/raos-famous-lemon-chicken-pollo-al-limone-recipe-212202729 Reviews1 hour
Pan Roasted Chicken Thighs with Grapes and Oliveshttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/pan-roasted-chicken-thighs-with-grapes-and-olives-22692694 Reviews40 minutes
20-Minute Shrimp and Couscous With Yogurt-Hummus Saucehttps://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/20-minute-shrimp-and-couscous-with-yogurt-hummus-sauce-recipe-212050518 Reviews20 minutes

How They Work

Broiling is a cooking method that uses dry heat (typically generated by a heat source located above the food) to produce intense heat.

A broiler pan is a rectangular piece of cookware, which you can use to broil your food. It’s ideal to cook food that’s relatively thin via broiling so that it doesn’t get charred by the intense heat.

According to expert cooks, broiling would work well for beef steaks, chops, fish steaks like swordfish and tuna, skinless chicken etc.

You may even broil vegetables well suited for the process such as chilies, peppers, and tomatoes using your broiler pan, which is normally built of heavy gauge steel or stainless steel with a black porcelain enamel. 

The pan has two sections – an upper cooking surface, which is the lid of the broiler plate; and a low walled pan section. The cooking surface holds the food while it broils, and has small holes or open slits on it, while the pan below comes handy to catch the drippings.

Since the lid or cooking surface comes equipped with only nominal openings, it keeps the drippings and hot grease enclosed within the pan, thus ensuring they don’t explode and burn the food’s bottom section as it broils.

How To Use

You should preheat the broiler pan before your food goes into it. Doing this would give your food a blast of heat as soon as it goes in. For foods such as steak, preheating the pan would give it a delicious searing effect. You can even buy some frozen meatballs or frozen lasagna and use your pan to heat them up so they have a nice crisp on them.

To ensure your food is cooked evenly, you should bring it to room temperature prior to broiling. In addition, remove moisture or marinade from it, if any, by patting it dry before you set it to broil. You can also use a butter sprayer to give your creation some extra taste. 

With broiling, you should remember that you are actually just cooking your food’s outer surface. That’s why this method works the best with fresh vegetables that cook fast, thin cuts of meat, and foods that are moderately tender, to begin with.

Since broiling is a fast cooking method, it would take at most 5 to 10 minutes to get your food ready. If you don’t keep a close eye on your food, and perhaps even check it every 2-3 minutes, it may go from being nicely seared to a disastrous charred variety. So, you shouldn’t walk away once your food is in the broiler pan.

You could even set a timer at 2-minute increments to remind you of checking how well the food is done. If you find the food browning too quickly or too slowly, you may even need to adjust your pan’s position a bit lower or higher respectively.

Broiler Pan Substitute

If you can’t buy a broiler pan of your choice, you may use some of the following alternative cookware:

  • Roasting pan
  • Cast iron pot or pan
  • Baking tray
  • Aluminum foil tray

Remember to stay away from using glass casseroles or dishes while broiling as the glass isn’t designed to endure extremely high temperatures.

Broil Vs. Grill

Though grilling is quite similar to broiling, the main difference is that the heat source here is positioned below the food, unlike broiling where the heat source is atop the food. During grilling, the food gets cooked by the heat generated from an electric element, charcoal, or gas. Another key differentiator between broiling and grilling is that while the former makes use of intense heat at all times, you can use variable heat for the latter – from low to moderate to high, depending on what your food needs.

Broiling Vs. Baking

While broiling is a high-intensity, faster cooking method, baking is a lower-intensity, slower cooking method. During baking, an electric element or a gas flame heats the air. This heat is then transferred to your food. Depending on what results you want to achieve, you can bake at low or high heat (Source).

While high heat would brown your foods just about as effectively as broiling or grilling, you may even use low heat for slow cooking of thicker and larger items like long-cooking, tougher cuts of meat etc.

The Top 5 Team

We are a team of product researchers that specializes in assembling comprehensive buying guides. Our team has a variety of backgrounds, with a mixture of soft and hard sciences represented. Check out our About page to read more about our reviews and editorial process.