Top5Reviewed is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The 5 Best Automatic Garage Door Closers [Ranked]

Automatic Garage Door Closers

Automatic garage door closers let you select how long you want your garage door to remain open after you have opened it.

Different automatic garage door closers have different programmed time settings, with the LiftMaster 888LM, for example, having 1, 5 and 10 minute settings, while the Magic Closer has 5, 15 minute and six hour delays.

Automatic garage door closers are great if you frequently forget to close your garage door, or if you are in and out of the garage many times a day and need a way to ensure that the garage door doesn't remain open for long periods of time.

The LiftMaster 888LM automatic garage door closer is our top pick- It is a particularly high-tech device that can actually be integrated with your tablet, smartphone or computer when paired with the (sold separately) 828LM LiftMaster internet gateway).

As is, this 40 W, 1.6 oz automatic garage door closer- it integrates with other security systems, as well- click below to watch a demo video.

Let's take a look at five of the best-selling automatic garage door closers on the market today and see how they compare.

Comparing The Options

The 5 Best Auto Garage Door Closers

Effectiveness

Price

Ease of Use

The Liftmaster 888LM is a great upgrade for anyone that is currently using a LiftMaster opener but doesn’t have 2.0 MYQ technology, as well as for new users. Adding this 888LM auto garage door closer allows you the security of not having to worry about your garage door being open because this unit allows users to control the garage door from their smartphone, tablet, or computer when used in combination with the 828LM LiftMaster internet gateway.

 

Users of the Liftmaster 888LM Security+ 2.0 MyQ Wall Control like the easy installation of the 888LM and the auto light feature while others have experienced some problems with the motion sensor. All in all, the Liftmaster 888LM is a solid choice for those looking for some additional peace of mind.

 

The general consensus regarding the LiftMaster is that this unit provides a reliable additional level of security for owners of older Liftmaster units. In addition, many have commented on how easy the 888LM control panel is to install and operate with the LiftMaster internet gateway (purchased separately).   

 

For example, one owner found the installation to be straightforward by only requiring two screws and two color coded wires. On the other hand, some users have found problems with signal interference which prevents the product from operating as advertised. Still, the feedback on the LiftMaster is overwhelmingly positive.

Video Overview

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Easy to operate
  • Reliable

Cons

  • Some signal interference when multiple units are in operation

Effectiveness

Price

Ease of Use

The Magic Closer automatic garage door closer is a simple to operate and simple to install garage closer for those looking to have a garage door that will close automatically when its smart sensor technology detects the door is open. The Magic Closer Door Closer provides the user with three settings of 5, 15 minute and 6-hour delay to determine when the door will automatically close, while also providing audio and visual warnings prior to doing so.

 

Users of the Magic Closer have commented on how they appreciate the easy installation of the unit and the good customer service provided by the manufacturer. Other users, however, have been frustrated by the cost and relatively short battery life of the Magic Closer. All in all, the Magic Closer is a simple and effective way to achieve the benefits of an automatic garage door closer.

 

One user of the Magic Closer commented on how it took him only five minutes to install the unit. When he did experience some problems with the unit he sent an email to the manufacturer and received a reply within 15 minutes on a Sunday. Other users, however, have been frustrated with the relatively short battery life of the Magic Closer.

 

For example, one user commented on how he had to replace the battery within 3 months of its installation. Still, the overall opinion of the Magic Closer is that it provides great value to its users by being simple to install and simple to use.

Video Overview

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Good customer service

Cons

  • Short battery life
  • Expensive batteries

Effectiveness

Price

Ease of Use

The Autocloser Automatic garage door closer is an excellent upgrade for those with older garage door units that want additional peace of mind by taking advantage of the latest garage-door-closing technology.

 

By incorporating microcontroller technology, infrared light sensors, and advanced software algorithms the Auto Closer is seen as a reliable and easy to install unit by most users. Although some have found the velcro tape used by the auto closer to be somewhat unreliable, the consensus of the auto closer is that is it is well priced and an effective upgrade for older garage door closers.

 

One user of the Autocloser automatic garage door closer has been using the unit for seven years and will be purchasing another unit when he moves into his new home. One of the features this user found most helpful is the disable button, which can be pressed for those times when the user wants to keep the garage door open.

 

The main complaint with respect to the auto closer garage door closer is with the velcro tape. When the tape loses its stickiness, the sensors can be misaligned and cause the garage door closer to malfunction. However, the overall opinion on the auto closer automatic garage door closer is that it is an excellent option for those looking to find an automatic garage door closer unit.

Video Overview

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Reliable technology

Cons

  • Velcro tape can misalign sensors

Effectiveness

Price

Ease of Use

Although the Garage Guardian automatic garage door closer and timer unit does not have all the features and technology of its competition, it is largely an effective and easy to install unit, that provides good value for its users. Black Device’s Garage Guardian works with all models and brands of garage door closers that do not already have MyQ technology.

 

Users of the Guardian Garage door closer like the simplicity of the systems; others users, however, found the Garage Guardian to be inconsistent in its operation and the foil tape which is used to hold the unit in place to be difficult to apply. All in all, given the low price of the Garage Guardian garage door closer, this device is a decent option for the value-conscious buyer.

 

Perhaps the strongest feature of the Garage Guardian garage door closer and timer is the ease of the installation. One user who has purchased two units of the Guardian automatic garage door closer commented that the first unit he installed took him 20 minutes to install, while the second unit took only 5 minutes.

 

On the other hand, some users have been frustrated with the tape used to hold the sensors in place, commenting that the tape is difficult to place and that they’re having problems with the tape holding the sensors which are vital to the operation of the unit. As a result, some users have not been able to enjoy proper operation the garage Guardian garage door closer.

 

In general, the Black Devices Garage Guardian automatic garage door closer, is a decent option for those looking for something that has a low-cost with basic functionality.

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Reliable operation

Cons

  • Tape can be difficult to install and unreliable

Effectiveness

Price

Ease of Use

The Chamberlain MyQ garage door opener is a versatile unit for those looking for additional functionality from their garage doors. The Chamberlain MYQ-G0201 gives users the ability to control their outdoor lights, house lamps and garage door with their smartphone.

 

Users have found that although the installation of the unit requires some savviness with technology, once the unit is properly set up it works as advertised. Other users have experienced inconsistencies with the MyQ Home Control smartphone application that is used by the Chamberlain garage door opener.

 

All in all, the Chamberlain myQ-G0201 is a solid option for the up for those users that are looking for more functionality and are willing to take the time to properly set up the device.

 

One user found the device to be highly functional and met his expectations after experimenting with the placement of his Wi-Fi hub. Other users, however, have been frustrated with the required tweaking of the Network configuration and software sensitivity. In general, the Chamberlain garage door opener is a device more appropriate for technology savvy users looking for additional functionality.

Pros

  • Customizable
  • Highly functional

Cons

  • Lengthy setup

What's The Big Idea?

Automatic garage doors are highly convenient methods of ensuring the security of your home and residence. You might be a soccer mom that is constantly heading in and out of the home through the garage-and you might frequently forget whether you have left the garage door open or not.

As well, perhaps you are hauling groceries in and out of your car and you just want the garage door to close after five minutes of being open that way you will have emptied the car of groceries and be safely in the house by the time the garage door automatically closes.

You can install an automatic garage door closer in multiple areas- the automatic garage door itself is usually powered by an electric motor that is hooked up to a metal track. Installation isn't always simple, however, was some users complaining that the battery life of their automatic garage door closers is not as long as they like, and that sometimes these sensors are incorrectly trapped, causing the garage doors to open at random times.

If you are particularly savvy, you can investigate integrating the automatic garage door closer with other security systems like keyless entry as well as your smartphone, tablet or computer- this can be part of a home-security system.

A garage closer can be a great way to save yourself time and aggravation as well as boosting the security of your home. If you're looking to purchase one of these automatic garage door closers, read our reviews on this page, check out the comparison table and read up on what other users have said subsequent to the purchase of a particular automatic garage door closer.

  • Updated September 22, 2019
  • Home
Top 5 Staff
 

We are a team of product researchers that specializes in assembling comprehensive buying guides. Our team has a variety of backgrounds, with a mixture of soft and hard sciences represented. Check out our About page to read more about our reviews and editorial process.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: